How many stamps to put on the card
The question is not “how many stamps” but “how often does your customer come back”. That is where the number comes from, and that is what decides whether the card gets completed or abandoned.
Start with frequency, not with the number
The question «how many stamps?» has no answer without another question first: how often does your regular customer come back today. A stamp card isn't a nice-looking number, it's a deadline dressed up as a number.
If someone comes three times a week, a 10-stamp card is three and a half weeks: they fill it, feel they've won something and start another. If they come once a fortnight, those same 10 stamps are five months. Nobody stays excited about a coffee for five months.
The number, on the back of a napkin
Multiply your average customer's visits per week by four. That's your number of stamps.
| How often they come | Visits in 4 weeks | Recommended stamps | Example business |
|---|---|---|---|
| Every weekday | 20 | 12 – 15 | Office-district café, bakery |
| 3 times a week | 12 | 10 – 12 | Neighbourhood café, gym |
| Twice a week | 8 | 8 – 10 | Fast food, poke, açaí |
| Once a week | 4 | 6 – 8 | Set-lunch restaurant, brunch |
| Twice a month | 2 | 5 – 6 | Dinner restaurant, hairdresser |
| Once a month or less | 1 | Don't use stamps | Use points for spend |
The last row is the important one and almost nobody respects it: if your customer comes once a month, a stamp card is no use to them. It'll take half a year to fill and by then they'll have forgotten it exists. What works there is a points balance based on what they spend, which goes up with every visit and doesn't demand reaching any finish line.
What it really costs you
The cost of a stamp programme isn't the price of the reward: it's the cost of the reward spread across all the visits it takes to earn it. And you work it out with the product cost, not the selling price.
| Reward | Costs you | Every | Cost per visit | On a €3 ticket |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Espresso | €0.40 | 10 stamps | €0.04 | 1.3% |
| White coffee + pastry | €1.10 | 10 stamps | €0.11 | 3.7% |
| Large drink | €0.70 | 8 stamps | €0.09 | 3.0% |
| Main course | €3.50 | 10 stamps | €0.35 | 11.7% |
2–4% is a reasonable investment in getting someone to come back. Above 10% you're no longer building loyalty, you're buying visits — and the day you remove the reward, they leave.
Where to put the rewards (not just at the end)
A card with a single reward at the end has a design problem: the first visits reward nothing. The customer gets three stamps, nothing happens, and they forget.
Spread them out. A 10-stamp card with rewards at the 5th and the 10th turns one long climb into two short ones:
- Stamp 5 · small reward — an extra, a topping, a size up. It costs you cents and buys you the second half of the card.
- Stamp 10 · the real reward — the one they'd tell a friend about.
A trick that works surprisingly well: make one of the in-between rewards a double stamp. It costs you no product, speeds the card up right in the boring middle, and the customer feels they've been done a favour.
Stamp per visit or stamp per amount
They're two different programmes, and choosing the wrong mode is the most expensive mistake:
| Per visit | Per amount | |
|---|---|---|
| When | Your ticket is always similar | Your ticket varies a lot |
| Example | Café, bakery, ice-cream shop | Restaurant, tapas bar |
| Rule | 1 stamp per visit, with a daily cap | 1 stamp for every €X spent |
| Risk | Someone spending €40 earns the same as the coffee customer | The daily customer feels they progress slowly |
With the per-amount mode there's a decision almost nobody sees coming: does a big purchase give several stamps or just one? If you give a stamp for every €10 and someone spends €30, they could get three stamps (by multiples) or just one. Both are defensible: by multiples you reward spend; with just one you reward the visit. What you can't do is leave it undecided — because your team will decide for you, each in their own way.
The four usual mistakes
- A card that's too long. 20 stamps sounds generous and is the opposite: nobody gets there. If you want to reward the very loyal, don't make the card longer — add tiers.
- A reward nobody wants. A 5% discount excites no one. A free product does. Give things away, not percentages.
- Starting from zero after the reward, and that's it. Going back to 0/10 the first time you win something feels like a punishment. That's where tiers come in: someone who has filled a card shouldn't go back to exactly the same place as a stranger.
- Never telling them how many they have left. The message that brings the most people back isn't «we have offers», it's «you're 1 stamp away». If your card lives on the mobile phone, that can be sent automatically.
On that last point we have a separate guide: what to write in the pass notification and when to send it.
Frequently asked questions
How many stamps should a loyalty card have?
Between 6 and 10 in hospitality. The rule of thumb: customers should be able to fill it in about 4 weeks, coming as often as they already do. If they come twice a week, 8 stamps is a month; if they come once a fortnight, 8 stamps is four months and they give up.
How much does a stamp card reward cost me?
The real cost is the product cost of the reward divided by the number of stamps on the card. A coffee that costs you €0.40, given away every 10 stamps, is 4 cents per visit: less than 2% of a €2.50 ticket.
Is one big reward at the end better than several small ones?
Several. A single reward at the end means the first visits feel like nothing. A small reward halfway through — an extra, a topping, a double stamp — keeps interest up exactly where people drop off.
Stamp per visit or stamp per amount spent?
Per visit if your ticket is always similar (a café). Per amount if it varies a lot (a restaurant), because rewarding a half-pint and a dinner for four the same way annoys the bigger spender.