Paper, app or Wallet: the three loyalty card formats
All three formats reward the same thing. What changes is how much effort it takes the customer to join, what you know about them afterwards and whether you can talk to them again.
The comparison, in one table
| Paper card | Your own app | Apple / Google Wallet | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it asks of the customer | Keep it in their wallet | Download, sign up, grant permissions | Scan a QR code and tap «Add» |
| You know who they are | No | Yes | Yes |
| You can reach them | No | Yes, if they accept notifications | Yes, on the card itself |
| Gets lost or forgotten | Often | Gets deleted if not used | It sits where they pay with their phone |
| Fraud | A fake stamp costs €3 | Low | Low: every card is unique |
| Cost to you | Printing | Development and maintenance, or a fee | Monthly fee |
| Several locations | Hard to reconcile | Yes | Yes, a single club |
Paper card: cheap, but blind
The paper stamp card works because everyone understands it. Its problem is not the format, it is that it gives you nothing back: you do not know who has one, how many are half full or who has stopped coming. And a rubber stamp identical to yours can be bought online for a few euros.
It is fine for testing the idea for a week. It is no good for managing customers.
Your own app: powerful, but with a heavy door
An app gives you everything: data, notifications, orders. The price is not just the development: it is the download. Every step you ask of the customer at the counter (find the app, download it, create an account, accept permissions) loses some of them, and to collect a stamp at a café hardly anyone does all four.
It makes sense for big brands whose customers already use the app for something else. For a single shop or a small chain, the door is too heavy.
A card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet: the middle ground
The card goes inside an app the customer already has: Wallet on the iPhone, Google Wallet on Android. Signing up is a QR code and a tap. From then on:
- It updates itself every time they get a stamp: the customer sees «7 of 10» without doing anything.
- It receives notifications on the lock screen, like any other notification, with no app.
- It carries your brand: your logo, your colours, your image.
- You know who they are: name and contact details, with their permission, so you can talk to them later.
The limit: the card design is set by Apple and Google (fixed sizes and fields). The exact measurements are in Apple Wallet pass sizes and in Google Wallet for a loyalty card.
Which to choose
- You want to try it without spending: paper card, knowing it is a trial.
- You are a big brand with an app people already use: add loyalty to your app.
- You are a single shop or a chain and want to know who comes back and reach them: a Wallet card. It is the format that asks the least of the customer to join.
If you are going for Wallet, before choosing a provider read the 12 questions to ask before you pay.
Frequently asked questions
What is an Apple Wallet loyalty card?
A card that lives in the iPhone Wallet app, the same one that holds boarding passes. The customer adds it from a QR code, it updates itself when they get a stamp and it can show notifications on the lock screen. On Android it works the same way with Google Wallet.
Does it work on Android?
Yes: on Android the card goes into Google Wallet. A good programme creates both versions at once from the same QR code, and each phone opens its own.
Does a paper card still make sense?
To start tomorrow without spending anything, yes. But it does not tell you who your customer is, you cannot get in touch with them and it is easy to fake. As soon as you want to know who comes back, it falls short.
When is your own app worth it?
When you are a brand with many locations and customers who already use your app for something else (ordering delivery, booking). For a single shop or a small chain, asking for a download just to collect stamps holds back sign-ups.